Should I Rent Out My House or Sell It?
Start with one question: why do you even want to keep it? If you can’t answer that in a sentence, selling is probably your answer.
Run your numbers in the calculator above first. Then use this guide to sanity-check the answer.
The short version: selling usually wins when the rent barely covers the costs and waiting would cost you a big tax break. Renting usually wins when the place cash flows, you’ve got a cheap mortgage, and you actually want to be a landlord (or hire one).
Worked Example: The Calculator’s Default Numbers
Here’s the example loaded above. A married couple owns a home worth $525,000. They paid $325,000, put $15,000 into improvements, and still owe $245,000. It would rent for $3,000 a month, with $550 a month in taxes, insurance and HOA. They’re comparing selling now with renting it out for 7 years.
Sell now: $525,000 minus $31,500 in selling costs (6%) and the $245,000 payoff leaves $248,500. Their $153,500 gain fits under the $500,000 married exclusion, so the tax is $0. Invested at 7% for 7 years, that grows to $399,037.
Rent for 7 years, then sell: the home grows to $667,947 and the loan drops to $193,303. But after 7 years as a rental, the exclusion is gone. They owe $53,108 in capital gains tax and $16,545 in depreciation recapture. Add $3,941 of reinvested cash flow and they end up with $368,854.
Selling wins by $30,183. The calculator also shows the two paths cross at year 4, so the hold period changes the answer. Slide it and watch.
Moral of the story… rent that doesn’t quite cover the costs (about $92 a month negative in year 1 here) plus a lost tax break is a tough combo to beat.
How the Calculator Works
No black box. Here’s exactly what it does with your numbers:
Sell now: home value minus selling costs, the loan payoff and any tax. That lump sum gets invested at your reinvestment rate.
Rent, then sell: each year’s cash flow (rent minus every expense) gets reinvested at the same rate, plus whatever you net when you sell at the end.
Reinvestment rate: defaults to 7%, a long-run stock market assumption. Drop it if you’d park the cash in savings. Raise it if you’re an active investor.
What it can’t predict: appreciation, rent growth and returns are educated guesses. Vacancies and repairs come in clumps, not smooth averages, so use at least a 5-year hold for a real decision.
What it leaves out: state income tax, the net investment income tax and other personal tax details. Run your final numbers with a CPA.
The Tax Rules That Decide Most Rent vs Sell Calls
The $250,000 / $500,000 home sale exclusion
If you owned and lived in the home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale, you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 on a joint return. That’s straight from IRS Topic 701 and 26 U.S.C. § 121.
Here’s the part people miss. The time it’s a rental after you move out doesn’t count against you, as long as you still pass the 2-of-5 test on the day you sell. So if you lived there 2 years, you’ve got about 3 years to rent it and still sell with the exclusion. IRS Publication 523 walks through exactly that case. That window closes on its own, so talk to a CPA before the clock runs out.
Depreciation recapture
While it’s a rental, you depreciate the building (not the land) over 27.5 years, per IRS Publication 527. That lowers your taxes every year. When you sell, the exclusion can’t cover that depreciation. Publication 523 says you can’t exclude gain equal to depreciation “allowed or allowable” after May 6, 1997, and IRS Topic 409 says that piece is taxed at a maximum 25% rate. “Allowable” means it counts even if you never claimed it.
The 1031 exchange
Rent it now and sell later, and you may be able to defer the gain by trading into another investment property with a 1031 like-kind exchange. The IRS Form 8824 instructions say the replacement property has to be identified within 45 days and received within 180 days (or by your tax return due date, if that’s sooner). Talk to a CPA before you list, not after.
When Renting It Out Makes Sense
Renting it out usually makes sense when:
It cash flows after a real budget: vacancy, repairs, big-ticket replacements, and management. Not just rent minus the mortgage.
You’ve got a low fixed-rate mortgage you couldn’t get again. A great rate is the best argument for keeping it.
You might move back, or you’ll sell inside the 2-of-5-year window anyway.
You’re OK being a landlord, or you’ll hire a manager.
You’ve got a real reason to think your neighborhood will beat the average: a big employer moving in, new roads, not enough homes. The calculator uses one appreciation rate for both paths, so it won’t catch that.
When Selling Makes More Sense
Selling usually makes more sense when:
The rent doesn’t cover the costs, so you’d be feeding the property every month.
You’ve got a big gain the exclusion covers today, and holding would cost you the exclusion.
You need the cash for a down payment, debt, or a business.
The house needs major work (roof, furnace, sewer line) before a tenant can move in.
You’d hate the 2 a.m. calls. Be honest with yourself on this one.
You’re done with the swings. One bad tenant or a new roof can wipe out a year of profit.
How to Get Your Inputs Right
Garbage in, garbage out. Four numbers move the answer the most:
Rent. Use real, recent rentals near you, not the high end of what you see online.
Home value. Use what it would actually sell for today. Then plan on about 9% to sell, not 6%, once commission, closing costs, concessions and prep work add up. The calculator defaults to 6%, so bump it in Advanced.
Hold period. Use how long you’d really keep it. Slide it between 3 and 7 years and watch the verdict.
Expenses. Count vacancy, repair reserves (1-2% of the home’s value a year) and management, even if you plan to manage it yourself.
Rent vs Sell FAQs
Can I still get the $250,000/$500,000 exclusion if I rent my house out first?
Yes, if you still meet the 2-of-5-year ownership and use tests on the day you sell. The depreciation from the rental years is still taxed.
Do I pay back depreciation when I sell a rental?
Yes. It’s taxed at up to 25% when you sell, even if the exclusion covers the rest of your gain.
How do I avoid capital gains tax on a rental?
If it was your home, sell inside the 2-of-5-year window. If it’s an investment, a 1031 exchange can defer the tax. Past that, it’s CPA territory.
How much does it cost to sell a house?
Plan on about 9% of the price once you add commission, title, closing costs, concessions and getting the house ready. The calculator starts at 6%, so adjust it to your real numbers. Publication 523 counts sales commissions as selling expenses, which lower your taxable gain.
Should I rent out my house to keep my low mortgage rate?
Maybe. A cheap rate is worth a lot, but only if the place cash flows or you’re fine feeding it for a while. Check the year-1 cash flow in the results above.
Keeping it? Read how to convert your primary residence to a rental and what changes when you’re selling a rental property with tenants. Want help with the landlord part? See Bellhaven property management. This is NOT tax advice.




