Property Management

Renters

Buyers

Sellers

Resources

Best Small Towns in Idaho to Live In (2026)

The best small town in Idaho depends on what you want: a low price, a fast-growing town near a city, or the mountains. Here are the standouts in each group, using real Census data instead of vibes.

Short answer: pick the type of town first, then the town.

  • Cheapest: American Falls, Gooding, Rupert, St. Anthony.

  • Near a city: Rigby, Kimberly, Iona, Shelley.

  • Mountain towns: Victor, McCall, Ketchum, at a price.

  • Resale: cheaper outlying towns sell slower.

Three small towns side by side: one with a low price tag, one near a city, one in the mountains

How we picked them

We looked at every Idaho town with 2,500 to 9,999 people in the Census Bureau’s 2025 population estimates, then compared median home value, median rent, and median household income from the Census Bureau’s 2020-2024 American Community Survey. Small towns have small survey samples, so treat every number here as a ballpark.

We left out schools, crime, and demographics on purpose. The numbers below tell you what you’ll pay and how fast a town is growing. Visit and decide the rest for yourself.

Best small towns in Idaho for a low price

Town

County

2025 population

Median home value

Median rent

American Falls

Power

4,785

$185,600

$737

Gooding

Gooding

3,855

$186,100

$861

Rupert

Minidoka

6,460

$205,200

$856

Weiser

Washington

6,249

$223,400

$927

St. Anthony

Fremont

3,990

$231,900

$793

All of these are well under Idaho’s median home value of $418,600 and the national median of $332,700. American Falls has the most affordable homes relative to local income of any town in this size range. Weiser has grown about 11% since 2020 and St. Anthony about 8%.

Best small towns near a bigger city

These are the fast-growing towns where people get small-town living and keep a city job within driving distance.

Town

Nearby city

Growth since 2020

Median home value

Median rent

Kimberly

Twin Falls

+25%

$339,400

$1,127

Fruitland

Ontario, OR

+19%

$329,600

$798

Iona

Idaho Falls

+17%

$420,300

$1,533

Emmett

Boise area

+16%

$342,000

$1,042

Rigby

Idaho Falls

+14%

$336,200

$1,180

Shelley

Idaho Falls

+11%

$295,200

$1,265

Rigby is our home base, and it’s a good example of the pattern: growing fast, priced about the same as Idaho Falls, with a small-town feel. More in our guide to living in Rigby. Shelley is the cheapest of the Idaho Falls-area towns on this list. Check the Shelley zoning rules before you buy anything with plans for a shop or ADU.

Best small mountain towns in Idaho

Mountain towns are the ones people dream about, and the prices show it.

Town

2025 population

Growth since 2020

Median home value

Median rent

Victor

2,589

+20%

$617,300

$1,405

McCall

4,133

+12%

$676,500

$1,134

Ketchum

3,643

+3%

$824,000

$1,186

Salmon

3,286

+6%

$235,500

$590

McCall and Ketchum home values run more than 11 and 8 times local income, the least affordable ratios of any small town in Idaho. Their survey estimates also have the widest margins, so the real numbers could be well above or below these. Victor is the fastest grower of the group. More in our guide to living in Driggs and Victor. Salmon is the outlier: a remote mountain town with some of the lowest prices and rents in the state.

Before you pick a small town

Cheap towns can be slow to resell

Small towns with low inventory tend to hold value. HOWEVER, cheaper outlying towns usually appreciate slower and take longer to sell. If you might move in three to five years, that matters more than the price.

Budget the whole payment

A cheap house far from work can cost more each month than a pricier one close in. Add up the mortgage, property tax, insurance, utilities, and the commute. A rule of thumb I use with buyers: every $10,000 of price adds roughly $60 a month.

File the homeowner’s exemption

Under Idaho Code § 63-602G, the homeowner’s exemption takes the lesser of $125,000 or 50% off the taxable value of the home you live in. Rates vary a lot by county, per the Idaho State Tax Commission’s 2025 averages, so check the parcel before you budget.

Check the well, the septic, and the zoning

Outside city limits, a lot of homes run on a private well and septic. Inspect both as part of your home inspection, and check the county zoning before you plan on animals, a shop, or a second home on the lot.

FREE GUIDE

Get the Homebuyer Savings Stack

Six money moves that can save you thousands on your first home, in a free five-minute guide. We’ll email it to you.

FAQs about small towns in Idaho

What is the cheapest small town in Idaho?

Among towns with 2,500 to 9,999 people, American Falls and Gooding have the lowest median home values, at about $185,600 and $186,100.

What is the fastest-growing small town in Idaho?

Among towns in that size range, Kimberly grew about 25% from 2020 to 2025, followed by Victor at about 20%.

What are the best small towns in eastern Idaho?

For value near Idaho Falls, look at Rigby, Shelley, and Iona. For a lower price, St. Anthony. For the mountains, Victor and Driggs in Teton Valley.

Looking at a small town in eastern Idaho?

We help buyers in Rigby, St. Anthony, Shelley, Teton Valley, and the rest of eastern Idaho, including people buying from out of state. Tell us your budget and where you work, and we’ll tell you honestly which town fits.

Talk to a Bellhaven buyer’s agent ->

Table of Contents
Back to Top
  1. Table of Contents
  2. Is your rental leaving money on the table?

    Run a free 5-minute checkup to find missed rent, fees, and savings.

    See My Profit Leaks