Can I Buy a House With Debt in Collections? (2026 Rules by Loan Type)
An old collection (or any other derogatory credit) on your report feels like a dealbreaker. Most of the time it isn’t. Here’s how each loan program actually handles it.
Short answer: usually, yes.
Conventional: no payoff needed on a 1-unit home you’ll live in.
FHA and USDA: over $2,000, pay it, set up a plan, or the lender counts 5% of it as a monthly debt.
VA: payoff isn’t required.
Judgments: almost always have to be paid.

Collection rules by loan type
Every loan program writes its own rule. Here’s how the four big ones handle collection accounts, straight from their guidelines.
Loan type | Do you have to pay collections off? | Medical and charge-offs | Judgments |
|---|---|---|---|
Conventional (Fannie Mae), 1-unit home you live in | No, regardless of the amount | Not required to be paid | Must be paid at or before closing |
Conventional, 2-4 units or second home | Only if the total is more than $5,000 | Medical excluded | Must be paid at or before closing |
Conventional, investment property or manual underwriting | Any account of $250 or more, or a total over $1,000 | Medical excluded | Must be paid at or before closing |
FHA | At $2,000 or more total: pay it, set up a payment plan, or count 5% of the balance | Medical isn’t counted as debt; charge-offs aren’t counted | Paid, or a payment plan with 3 on-time payments |
VA | Not mandatory | Lender looks at the whole credit picture | Must be paid before the loan is approved |
USDA | Over $2,000 in non-medical: pay it, set up a payment plan, or count 5% of the balance | Neither has to be paid | Paid, or 3 on-time payments |
Conventional loans
Under Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide (B3-5.3-09), if you’re buying a one-unit home to live in and the loan runs through Desktop Underwriter (Fannie Mae’s automated underwriting system), you aren’t required to pay off collections or non-mortgage charge-offs, regardless of the amount. On a 2-4 unit home or a second home, they have to be paid if they total more than $5,000. On an investment property, it’s any single account of $250 or more, or a total over $1,000.
If your loan is manually underwritten instead, Fannie Mae’s rule for debts paid at closing (B3-6-07) uses that same $250 and $1,000 line. Freddie Mac loans follow Freddie’s own guide, so ask your lender which one your loan is going to.
Not required to pay doesn’t mean invisible. The collection still shows up on your credit report and still hits your score, and a lower score usually means a higher rate.
FHA loans
FHA is where the 5% rule lives. HUD Handbook 4000.1 says that once your collection balances add up to $2,000 or more, the lender has to pick one of three options: the collections get paid in full at or before closing, you have a payment arrangement and that payment counts in your debt-to-income ratio, or the lender counts 5% of each collection’s balance as a monthly payment.
Medical collections are listed as obligations not considered debt, and charge-off accounts don’t have to be included in your debts at all. In a community property state, a non-borrowing spouse’s collections count toward the $2,000 too.
VA loans
The VA’s credit standards in 38 CFR 36.4340 say it isn’t mandatory that a collection account be paid off for the loan to be approved. The lender still weighs your whole credit history. See how a VA-guaranteed loan works for the rest of the rules. Court-ordered judgments are different: they have to be paid off before a new loan is approved.
USDA loans
USDA works a lot like FHA. Its HB-1-3555 credit matrix says that if non-medical collections total more than $2,000, you pay them, set up a repayment agreement, or the lender counts 5% of the balance as a monthly payment. USDA doesn’t require medical collections or charge-offs to be paid.
How the FHA 5% rule hits your budget: a worked example
Picture this. You earn $6,000 a month before taxes. You have a $380 car payment and a $45 credit card minimum. The house you want comes with a $1,900 payment, including taxes and insurance.
Without the collections, your debt-to-income ratio is $2,325 ÷ $6,000 = 38.75%.
Now add $4,200 in old non-medical collections. That’s over FHA’s $2,000 line, so here are your three options:
Option | Monthly debt added | DTI | Cash needed now |
|---|---|---|---|
Lender counts 5% of $4,200 | $210 | 42.25% | $0 |
Payment plan with the collector at $75 a month | $75 | 40.00% | $0 (plus proof of the plan) |
Pay it all off before closing | $0 | 38.75% | $4,200 |
That $210 a month matters more than it looks. My rule of thumb is that every $10,000 of house costs roughly $60 to $70 a month. So a $210 payment that only exists on paper can eat about $30,000 to $35,000 of what you can buy. You can test your own numbers with our home affordability calculator.

On a tight file, 3.5 points of DTI can be the difference between an approval and a no. On a strong file, the lender might just count the 5% and you keep your $4,200 for closing.
Should I pay off collections before buying a house?
Maybe. But not before you talk to your lender.
When buyers ask me which debt to pay off, I look at it the same way every time: how much monthly payment does it remove, and how much cash does it cost? Paying off a small balance can free up the same room as a big one. If your lender says pay it off, it’s probably because your DTI needs it. If they don’t, that cash might be worth more as your down payment or closing costs.
There are a few more reasons not to just start paying things off on your own:
Does paying off collections raise your credit score?
Not always. myFICO says FICO Score 9 and FICO 10 ignore collections that are paid in full, but paying one off could make your score go up, down, or not move at all depending on the model. Mortgage lenders don’t use the same score your credit card app shows you.
That’s changing a little. The FHFA says Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac opened VantageScore 4.0 to all approved lenders on September 9, 2026, while Classic FICO is still allowed with no retirement date announced. So which score your lender pulls depends on your lender.
Old debts and the statute of limitations
A collection can stay on your credit report for about seven years. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. § 1681c), that clock runs from when the account first went delinquent, not from when a collector bought it.
The statute of limitations is a separate clock. It’s how long a collector can sue you. The CFPB says most states set it between three and six years, and in some states making a partial payment or admitting you owe an old debt can restart it.
Here in Idaho, for example, it’s five years for a debt based on a written contract under Idaho Code § 5-216, and four years for an unwritten one under Idaho Code § 5-217. A $50 good-faith payment on a six-year-old debt can cause more trouble than it fixes. Check your state’s rule before you pay anything old.
Your lender pulls credit twice
Lenders pull your credit at pre-approval and again right before closing. If you settle accounts, open new ones, or buy furniture on credit in between, your file changes. Make changes with your lender, not around them.
Credit is a file, not a score
This is the part most people get backwards. Your score is a number an algorithm made up. Your credit file is the story behind it, and underwriters read the story.
Two files can tell very different stories. Someone at 675 with 30 accounts paid on time for 12 years and a few late payments six years ago looks like a reliable borrower with one rough stretch. Someone at 725 with one $400-limit card and six months of history doesn’t have much of a story yet.
One old collection with years of clean payments since is a very different file from a stack of new ones. Recent payment history is what decides most of these. If you’ve paid everything on time since the collection, that counts.
Medical collections, charge-offs, and judgments
Medical collections
Medical debt gets a break almost everywhere. Fannie Mae excludes medical collections from its payoff limits, FHA doesn’t count them as debt, and USDA doesn’t require them to be paid.
On your credit report, the CFPB reported that Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion removed paid medical debt, stopped reporting medical collections under $500, and wait a year before medical debt can show up. A broader federal rule banning medical debt from credit reports was vacated by a federal court in July 2025, per the CFPB’s rule page, so larger unpaid medical collections can still appear.
Charge-offs
A charge-off means the original lender wrote the debt off as a loss. It still hurts your score, but FHA doesn’t count charge-offs in your debts, USDA doesn’t require them to be paid, and Fannie Mae doesn’t require payoff on a one-unit home you’ll live in.
Judgments
A judgment is what you get when a creditor sues you and wins. This is the one that can actually stop a closing. A judgment can turn into a judgment lien, and liens can attach to the house you’re buying, which fights with the lender’s need to be first in line. Fannie Mae, FHA, VA, and USDA all want judgments paid, and FHA and USDA allow a payment plan only after three on-time payments.

Disputed collections
Disputing a collection right before you apply can backfire. Under the HUD handbook, $1,000 or more in disputed non-medical derogatory accounts knocks an FHA loan into manual underwriting. USDA uses a $2,000 line. If the account is truly wrong, dispute it early. The CFPB says companies generally have 30 days to investigate.
What to do before you apply
Here’s the order I’d go in if I were you:
Pull all three credit reports. Write down every collection: who it’s owed to, the balance, the date it first went late, and whether it’s medical.
Get pre-approved and understand your program options. A pre-approval letter means a lender has actually pulled your credit. Conventional, FHA, VA, and USDA treat the same collections differently, so the right program can change the whole answer.
Ask your lender which accounts to resolve. Ask which ones, how, and whether a payment plan works better than a payoff. Get it before you spend a dollar.
Handle judgments first. They’re the ones most likely to block closing.
Keep everything else quiet. No new cards, no car loans, and keep card balances around 10% of your limits until you have the keys.
This isn’t lending advice. Rules change and they vary by loan program, so your lender has the final say on your file.
FREE GUIDE
Get the Homebuyer Savings Stack
Six money moves that can save you thousands on your first home, in a free five-minute guide. We’ll email it to you.
FAQs
Can you buy a house with unpaid collections?
Yes. A conventional loan on a one-unit home you live in doesn’t require collections to be paid, VA doesn’t require it, and FHA and USDA have workarounds once you’re past $2,000. Unpaid judgments are the main exception.
How long after paying off collections can you buy a house?
The loan rules above don’t set a waiting period after a collection is paid, so you can apply as soon as it’s done. Just keep the receipt or the paid-in-full letter, because the lender may ask for it.
Can I get a mortgage with a charge-off?
Usually, yes. FHA doesn’t count charge-offs as debt, USDA doesn’t require them to be paid, and Fannie Mae doesn’t require payoff on a one-unit home you’ll live in. Expect it to weigh on your score and your rate, though.
Do I have to pay a debt collector if they’re not the original creditor?
A collector can own or service the debt even if you never did business with them. If you don’t think you owe it, the CFPB says you generally have 30 days after the collector’s first notice to dispute all or part of it.
What happens if you never pay collections?
The account can stay on your report for about seven years from the first delinquency. Inside your state’s statute of limitations, the collector can sue, and a judgment is much harder to buy a house around than a collection.
Get ready before you start shopping
Collections are usually a speed bump, not a wall. The buyers who get stuck are the ones who find out late, after they’ve fallen in love with a house. Know your file, know your program, and walk in pre-approved.






