Living in Rexburg, Idaho: Honest Pros and Cons (2026)
Rexburg is a college town just up the road from our office in Rigby. Here’s what it really costs and what I’d tell a friend before they move.
Short answer: it’s a good fit if you like a busy, college-town pace and can handle cold winters.
Homes: pricier than Idaho Falls or Pocatello.
Rentals: mostly built around students.
Jobs: the university and the hospital lead.
Winter: about 14 nights a year below zero.

Is Rexburg a good place to live?
For a lot of people, yes. Rexburg has about 40,300 people, per the Census Bureau’s 2025 estimate. It’s home to BYU-Idaho, which reported 24,111 campus-based students in fall 2026, with about 22,000 of them living in Rexburg, per the university’s fall 2026 enrollment report.
That shapes everything. The town is busy during the semester and quieter in between. Housing, rentals, and a lot of local business revolve around the school calendar.
Cost of living in Rexburg
Here are the four costs that matter most: the house, the property tax, the power bill, and state taxes.
Home prices
The median home value in Rexburg is $395,100, according to the Census Bureau’s 2020-2024 American Community Survey. That’s above the national median of $332,700 and about $59,600 above Idaho Falls at $335,500. Using my rule of thumb that every $10,000 of price adds roughly $60 a month, that gap is about $360 a month.
Prices climbed hard and then slowed. The FHFA’s county house price index for Madison County rose about 66% from 2019 to 2022, then only about 5% from 2022 to 2025.
Rent
Median rent in Rexburg is $1,004 in that same Census survey. Don’t read too much into it. A big share of Rexburg rentals are student housing, often rented by the room, so the median doesn’t compare cleanly with a normal family rental. If you’re renting a whole house, expect to pay more than that number and to start looking early.
Property taxes after the homeowner’s exemption
Under Idaho Code § 63-602G, the homeowner’s exemption takes the lesser of $125,000 or 50% off the taxable value of the home you live in. Madison County’s average urban property tax rate was 0.923% in 2025, per the Idaho State Tax Commission. Here’s a rough estimate on a median-priced home:
Median-priced home | You live in it | Rental or second home |
|---|---|---|
Assessed value | $395,100 | $395,100 |
Homeowner’s exemption | -$125,000 | $0 |
Taxable value | $270,100 | $395,100 |
Tax at about 0.923% | About $2,490 a year ($208/mo) | About $3,650 a year ($304/mo) |
That’s about $1,150 a year for filing one form. This uses the county average, so your actual rate depends on your tax area. Check your parcel with the county before you budget.
Utilities and state taxes
Madison County is served by Rocky Mountain Power and Fall River Electric, depending on the address. In EIA’s 2025 utility data, their Idaho residential customers paid about 13.5 and 11.1 cents per kilowatt-hour on average, against a U.S. average of 17.23 cents. Ask for a year of bills before you write an offer.
Idaho’s sales tax is 6% under Idaho Code § 63-3619, groceries included. The income tax is a flat 5.3% under Idaho Code § 63-3024.
Jobs in Rexburg
BYU-Idaho is Madison County’s biggest employer, with 1,000 to 2,499 workers, per the Idaho Department of Labor’s county profile. The Madison School District and Madison Memorial Hospital follow, then Walmart, Melaleuca, the City of Rexburg, and others.
Madison County’s unemployment rate was 4.3% in October 2026, against 3.7% for Idaho and 4.1% nationally, per the Idaho Department of Labor. Idaho Falls is close enough that its bigger job market matters too.
If your work is seasonal or part-year, line up steady income before you buy. Lenders look hard at income that stops part of the year. Get a pre-approval once it’s real.
What winter is really like
Rexburg winters are cold. NOAA’s 1991-2020 climate normals for the BYU-Idaho station put the average January high at about 30°F and the low at about 14°F. The annual normals show about 14 nights a year below zero and about 12.6 inches of precipitation. Summers are pleasant, with July highs around 85°F.
Frozen pipes are the big homeowner risk. Disconnect hoses before the first hard freeze, and keep the heat at 55°F or higher if you leave town. Some insurers deny frozen-pipe claims when the heat was off.
Rexburg vs nearby towns
Here’s how Rexburg compares with its neighbors, using the same Census sources:
Town | 2025 population | Growth since 2020 | Median home value | Median rent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Rexburg | 40,334 | +1% | $395,100 | $1,004 |
Sugar City | 2,476 | +44% | $350,000 | $1,330 |
Rigby | 5,757 | +14% | $336,200 | $1,180 |
Idaho Falls | 71,785 | +9% | $335,500 | $1,075 |
Sugar City sits just north of Rexburg and has grown fast from a small base. Its value estimate comes from a small sample, so treat it as rough. Rigby, our home base, is on the way to Idaho Falls and runs a little cheaper. More on living in Rigby and living in Idaho Falls.
Before you buy anything with plans for a shop, an ADU, or a rental, check the Rexburg zoning rules.
Pros and cons of living in Rexburg
The pros:
A busy town with a university, a hospital, and steady demand
Low property taxes on the home you live in
Power bills under the national average
Idaho Falls, Yellowstone, and the Tetons within day-trip range
The cons:
Home prices above Idaho Falls and Pocatello
A rental market built around students
Cold winters
Sales tax on groceries
My advice if you’re moving to Rexburg
1. Rent first if you won’t stay five to seven years
If you’ll be here five to seven years or more, buying usually wins. If it’s three to five, renting is often the smarter move. Run the numbers in our rent vs buy calculator.
2. Think about resale before you buy near campus
A home near campus can be easy to rent but harder to sell to a family later. Decide whether you’re buying a home or an investment, and buy for that buyer.
3. File the homeowner’s exemption the month you move in
File with the Madison County assessor as soon as the house is your primary home. If you missed it, ask whether past years can be fixed.
4. Start your search before winter
Winter is slower, not dead. The real dead zone is Thanksgiving through Christmas. If you’re renting with pets, start early, because pet-friendly rentals get scarce once the snow flies.
FREE GUIDE
Get the Homebuyer Savings Stack
Six money moves that can save you thousands on your first home, in a free five-minute guide. We’ll email it to you.
FAQs about living in Rexburg
Is Rexburg expensive to live in?
Home prices are above average for eastern Idaho, with a median value of $395,100. Property tax on an owner-occupied home is moderate once the exemption is filed, and power runs well under the national average.
How cold does it get in Rexburg?
The average January low is about 14°F, and about 14 nights a year drop below zero.
What is the population of Rexburg?
About 40,300 as of the Census Bureau’s July 2025 estimate. Madison County as a whole is about 55,200.
Is Rexburg or Idaho Falls better to live in?
Idaho Falls is bigger, cheaper on average, and has more job variety. Rexburg is smaller and centered on the university. They’re close enough that you can live in one and work in the other.
Thinking about moving to Rexburg?
We help buyers in Rexburg, Rigby, Idaho Falls, and the rest of eastern Idaho, including people buying from out of state. Tell us your timeline and budget, and we’ll tell you honestly where your money goes furthest.






